Thursday, November 24, 2022
HomePhilosophyAugustine on divine punishment of the good alongside the wicked

Augustine on divine punishment of the good alongside the wicked

Many right now
labor beneath the delusion that the actuality of struggling is a problem for
Christianity – as if Christian doctrine would lead us to anticipate little or no
struggling, in order that its adherents ought to be flummoxed by struggling’s
prevalence.  As I’ve mentioned in earlier
articles, that is the reverse of the fact. 
The Catholic religion teaches that struggling is
the inexorable consequence
of unique sin and previous precise sin.  It
is a vital half
of the lengthy and painful course of of
sanctification, of overcoming sinful habits of thought and motion.  It is the inevitable concomitant of the
persecution Christians should face for preaching the Gospel and condemning the
world’s wickedness.  It is an inescapable
punishment for sin, which we should embrace in a penitential spirit.  By method of struggling we pay each our personal temporal
debt and that of others for whom we’d supply up our struggling.  By method of it we most intently unite ourselves
to Christ’s Passion.  The extent and
depth of human struggling thus confirms
quite than disconfirms the claims of Christianity.

As I
proposed in these earlier articles, bafflement at struggling is much less the trigger than the consequence of the trendy West’s apostasy from the Catholic
religion.  It additionally displays the softness and
decadence of a dying civilization that has grow to be accustomed to affluence and can’t
fathom a better good past ease and past this life, for the sake of which we
may embrace struggling.  Nor is it
apostates alone who exhibit this blindness. 
The religious rot has eaten its method deep into the Church, afflicting
even those that are in any other case loyal to orthodoxy and Christian morality.  And in our disinclination to just accept
struggling, we’re solely making certain ourselves extra of it.

Here as
elsewhere, the nice St. Augustine sees clearly and speaks frankly the place we
moderns deceive ourselves and obfuscate. 
In chapters 8-10 of
Book I of The City of God, he discusses how and
why evil and struggling befall the good in addition to the wicked on this life.  As our personal age descends into ever deeper
ethical, political, social, and financial dysfunction, we’d do properly to meditate
upon his bracing instructing.  If the
devoted consider they’ll or must be spared the brunt of the punishment
that the sins of our civilization are liable to carry down upon it, they’re
sorely mistaken.  Things are more likely to
worsen for all of us, even when solely in order that divine windfall can finally
carry one thing higher out of the chaos.

In chapter
8, Augustine notes that whereas there’s on this life some connection between evildoing and struggling on the one hand,
and righteousness and blessings on the different, it is rather removed from tight.  The wicked take pleasure in many good issues, whereas the
good undergo a lot misfortune.  To ensure,
this will likely be redressed in the afterlife, when the good will likely be rewarded with
everlasting happiness and the wicked with everlasting torment.  “But as for the good issues of this life, and
its ills,” Augustine writes, “God has willed that these ought to be widespread to
each; that we’d not too eagerly covet the issues which wicked males are seen
equally to take pleasure in, nor shrink with an unseemly concern from the ills which even
good males typically undergo.” 

When we
marvel why God permits us to undergo regardless that we attempt to obey him, half of the
cause is exactly that we could be
.  For if we pursue
righteousness solely when it’s simple to take action, our advantage is sure to be shallow
and unlikely to final.  Nor, if the
connection between virtuous conduct and materials blessings is just too tight, are
we more likely to pursue the former for the proper causes.  We can’t obtain happiness in the world to come back
if we grow to be too connected to the world that’s, and struggling is a way of
stopping the latter.

says Augustine, the distinction between a very righteous man and a wicked one
is usually uncovered exactly by struggling:

Wherefore, although good and dangerous males
undergo alike, we should not suppose that there isn’t a distinction between the males
themselves, as a result of there isn’t a distinction in what they each undergo.  For even in the likeness of the sufferings,
there stays an unlikeness in the victims; and although uncovered to the identical
anguish, advantage and vice will not be the identical factor.  For as the identical hearth causes gold to glow
brightly, and chaff to smoke… so the identical violence of affliction proves,
purges, clarifies the good, however damns, ruins, exterminates the wicked.  And thus it’s that in the identical affliction
the wicked detest God and blaspheme, whereas the good pray and reward.  So materials a distinction does it make, not
what ills are suffered, however what variety of man suffers them

Now, to this point
Augustine is addressing struggling that’s unmerited.  But there’s additionally struggling that good males can
benefit and produce upon themselves, as Augustine explains in chapter 9.  This is so in a number of methods.  First, of course, no one’s excellent.  Even those that keep away from the extra blatant
violations of Christian morality nonetheless usually exhibit ethical failings of
numerous lesser varieties:

Although they be removed from the
excesses of wicked, immoral, and ungodly males, but they don’t decide themselves
so clear faraway from all faults as to be too good to undergo for these even
temporal ills.  For each man, nonetheless
laudably he lives, but yields in some factors to the lust of the flesh.  Though he don’t fall into gross enormity of
wickedness, and deserted viciousness, and abominable profanity, but he slips
into some sins, both not often or a lot the extra ceaselessly as the sins appear
of much less account

But there’s
additionally the angle that the good man takes towards those that do stay particularly
wicked lives.  There are many who
disapprove of such wickedness and would by no means apply it themselves, however who
nonetheless, out of cowardice, chorus from criticizing it in others.  Here Augustine makes some remarks which might be
particularly related to our instances, and price quoting at size:

Where can we readily discover a man who
holds in match and simply estimation these individuals on account of whose revolting
pleasure, luxurious, and avarice, and cursed iniquities and impiety, God now smites
the earth as His predictions threatened?  Where is the man who lives with them in the
model wherein it turns into us to stay with them?  For typically we wickedly blind ourselves to the
events of instructing and admonishing them, typically even of reprimanding and
chiding them, both as a result of we shrink from the labor or are ashamed to offend
them, or as a result of we concern to lose good friendships, lest this could stand in
the method of our development, or injure us in some worldly matter, which both
our covetous disposition needs to acquire, or our weak point shrinks from
shedding.  So that, though the conduct of
wicked males is distasteful to the good, and subsequently they don’t fall with them
into that damnation which in the subsequent life awaits such individuals, but, as a result of
they spare their damnable sins by way of concern, subsequently, regardless that their very own
sins be slight and venial, they’re justly scourged with the wicked on this
world, although in eternity they fairly escape punishment.  Justly, when God afflicts them in widespread with
the wicked, do they discover this life bitter, by way of love of whose sweetness they
declined to be bitter to those sinners

Augustine teaches that it’s not sufficient to chorus from the sins of wicked
males.  The Christian should additionally criticize them for his or her wickedness, and
attempt to get them to repent of it.  To be
positive, Augustine goes on to acknowledge that there could also be events the place one
may justifiably decide to postpone such criticism till an opportune second, or
chorus from it out of an affordable concern of doing extra hurt than good.  But he teaches right here that it’s not justifiable to chorus from such
criticism merely as a result of it’s tough, or as a result of we concern inflicting offense
and shedding buddies, or as a result of we don’t need to threat shedding standing or different
worldly items.  For the wicked are in
hazard of damnation if they don’t
repent, and we “wickedly blind ourselves” if we shirk our obligation to encourage
them to take action.  Even if we keep away from
damnation ourselves, we’ll justly undergo alongside them when divine
windfall visits this-worldly
punishments upon them (social and financial dysfunction, pure disasters, and the

Here too Augustine
emphasizes that God permits the good to undergo alongside the wicked partly to
wean them from their attachment to this world, the place their reluctance to
criticize the wicked is a symptom of this attachment:

What is blame-worthy is, that they
who themselves revolt from the conduct of the wicked, and stay in fairly one other
vogue, but spare these faults in different males which they must reprehend and
wean them from; and spare them as a result of they concern to present offense, lest they
ought to injure their pursuits in these issues which good males could innocently and
legitimately use – although they use them extra greedily than turns into individuals who
are strangers on this world, and profess the hope of a heavenly nation

Augustine is
particularly laborious on Christians (resembling clergy) who don’t have household
obligations and the like to fret about, but nonetheless shrink from doing their obligation
to sentence the wickedness that surrounds them:

[They] do typically take thought of their
personal security and good title, and abstain from discovering fault with the wicked,
as a result of they concern their wiles and violence. 
And though they don’t concern them to such an extent as to be drawn to
the fee of like iniquities, nay, not by any threats or violence soever;
but these very deeds which they refuse to share in the fee of they typically
decline to seek out fault with, when presumably they may by discovering fault stop
their fee.  They abstain from
interference, as a result of they concern that, if it fail of good impact, their very own
security or fame could also be broken or destroyed; not as a result of they see that
their preservation and good title are needful, that they are able to
affect those that want their instruction, however quite as a result of they weakly
relish the flattery and respect of males, and concern the judgments of the folks,
and the ache or dying of the physique; that’s to say, their non-intervention is
the end result of selfishness, and never of love

software to the current day is clear. 
Consider the sexual sins into which our age has, arguably, sunk extra
deeply than any earlier one.  So as to
keep away from criticizing these sins too harshly and even speaking a lot about them in any respect,
even many in any other case conservative Christians mislead themselves about their
gravity, pretending they’re slight when in truth (and as the custom has
all the time insisted) they’re extraordinarily severe. 
Such sins have, amongst their penalties: the even graver sin of homicide,
in the type of abortion; fatherlessness and the poverty and social breakdown
that’s its sequel; habit to pornography and the marital issues it brings
in its wake; the loneliness and financial insecurity of girls who of their youth
have been utilized by males for pleasure, and are later unable to seek out husbands; a normal
breakdown in rationality that has now reached the level the place even the
goal distinction between women and men is shrilly denied; and the
willingness to mutilate kids’s our bodies in the title of this gender ideology.

Worse, many Christians
deceive themselves into considering that it’s love or compassion for the sinner
that stops them from condemning these sins too harshly.  In truth, given the grave harm attributable to these
sins, and the issue so many have in extricating themselves from them, to
chorus from warning others towards them is the reverse of compassionate. 
Yet the current age is so hooked on them that, of all sins, sexual
sins are these criticism of which places the critic at best hazard.  People concern for his or her reputations, and even
livelihoods, in the event that they communicate up.  Hence, as
Augustine says, “their non-intervention is the end result of selfishness, and never
of love.”

consequence, Augustine teaches, is that many sinners who may need repented
had they been warned will find yourself damned because of this.  And those that did not warn them will undergo
not less than temporal punishments together with them, as a result of they have been too connected
to the comforts of this life to assist others put together for the subsequent.  Augustine writes:

Accordingly this appears to me to be
one principal cause why the good are chastised together with the wicked, when God
is happy to go to with temporal punishments the profligate manners of a
group.  They are punished collectively,
not as a result of they’ve spent an equally corrupt life, however as a result of the good as
properly as the wicked, although not equally with them, love this current life; whereas
they ought to carry it low cost, that the wicked, being admonished and reformed by
their instance, may lay maintain of life everlasting… For as long as they stay, it
stays unsure whether or not they could not come to a greater thoughts.  These egocentric individuals have extra trigger to concern
than these to whom it was mentioned by way of the prophet,
He is taken away in his iniquity, however
his blood will I require at the watchman’s hand (Ezekiel 33:6).

In chapter
10, Augustine hammers on the theme that the treasure of Christians is to be
present in heaven and never in any of the items of this life, and that,
accordingly, no worldly struggling can presumably really hurt them.  He writes:

They ought to endure all torment, if
want be, for Christ’s sake; that they could be taught to like Him quite who
enriches with everlasting felicity all who are suffering for Him, and never silver and gold,
for which it was pitiable to undergo, whether or not they preserved it by telling a lie
or misplaced it by telling the fact.  For
beneath these tortures nobody misplaced Christ by confessing Him…  So that presumably the torture which taught them
that they need to set their affections on a possession they may not lose, was
extra helpful than these possessions which, with none helpful fruit in any respect,
disquieted and tormented their anxious house owners

As this final
comment signifies, the loss of worldly blessings – materials items, fame, friendships,
well being, livelihood, even life itself – is permitted by God in order that we’d
study to not cling to those issues at the expense of the beatific imaginative and prescient, the
worth of which trumps all else.  God thus
solely ever permits struggling not in spite of his goodness, however quite exactly
as a result of of his goodness.  As Augustine
says, there isn’t “any evil [that] occurs to the devoted and godly which
can’t be turned to revenue,” in order that, with St. Paul, “we all know that each one issues
work collectively for good to them that love God” (Romans 8:28).


Most Popular

Recent Comments