Tuesday, March 7, 2023
HomeBuddhistThe Bird in the Cage Dilemma

The Bird in the Cage Dilemma

C. Pierce Salguero contemplates the karmic framework in Buddhism and the way it informs life’s moral dilemmas.

Photo by Ojaswi Pratap Singh.

One of the first instances I visited a Buddhist temple in Thailand, I noticed {that a} girl had arrange a stall out entrance in order to promote birds in small bamboo cages. The thought was to purchase a fowl from her and set it free. Since you’re liberating a dwelling being from struggling, that is an act of generosity that may earn you some good karma or “merit.”

Karma, or the notion that every one of our actions have moral penalties, is a standard function of many Indian spiritual and philosophical traditions. The widespread view of karma amongst Buddhists is that it’s one thing like a cosmic checking account with credit and debits that have an effect on your wellbeing and happiness in this life in addition to figuring out the situations of future reincarnations. In figuring out whether or not your actions are helpful or dangerous, Buddhism locations lots of significance on the intention behind them. More than the motion or its outcomes, it’s the intention that issues above all else.

Thinking in phrases of karma doesn’t give us pat solutions to those questions, nevertheless it provides us instruments to assist transfer previous a simplistic understanding of ethics

This can result in complicated conditions in which the proper factor to do is exceedingly tough to untangle. For instance, I initially thought that folks shopping for birds and setting them free from their cages was a pleasant thought. But as I used to be about to purchase them, I observed that the girl’s son was catching the launched birds with a web. He was placing them again into cages and returning them to his mom in order for her to promote them time and again.

What are the karmic implications right here? My first impulse was to purchase a fowl, to do a very good deed by liberating it. But then I found that by shopping for a fowl, I used to be in reality supporting an operation that was repeatedly ensnaring birds, inflicting them struggling for revenue. Having found that, ought to I purchase a fowl or not? Maybe not.

Thinking additional, although, I may additionally see the karmic ambiguity of this operation for the girl and her son. They are trapping birds and holding them for ransom. Surely, that should be unhealthy karma for them. But, by doing so, they’re giving the temple guests the alternative to make benefit, which absolutely should imply good karma for them. So, perhaps I ought to assist their operation in spite of everything, as a result of it’s producing helpful karma for many folks?

But wait! As I thought of it even additional, I found one other layer of consideration. As a Western traveler in Thailand, I’ve much more privilege and cash than this rural Thai household who has to interact in such a paradoxical career in order to eke out a dwelling. Maybe, I assumed, I can buy the entire lot of birds directly and set all of them free. Maybe I can buy the bird-sellers out for the entire day to allow them to go residence and relaxation.

Ah, sure, however then, gained’t I’ve despatched the message to the neighborhood you can doubtlessly earn some huge cash from vacationers in this bird-trapping career? And gained’t then much more folks be out right here promoting birds tomorrow?

What’s the neatest thing to do in this case? What would you’ve gotten carried out?

The Buddhist notion of karma normally gained’t offer you a straight reply about what’s proper and what’s flawed in any specific state of affairs. It’s not a black-or-white system of guidelines or a easy equation. It’s extra like a framework for considering by means of the moral implications of your choices inside a bigger image that’s ever increasing and extra complicated. It’s a self-reflective follow that asks you to consider an rising variety of variables every time you take a look at it.

The birds in the cage are only one small instance of how complicated ethics can get when you begin considering with karma. More sophisticated situations, akin to politics, battle, or local weather change, contain many extra variables. Sorting out the proper factor to do in real-life conditions involving numerous completely different actors who’re affected in alternative ways may be enormously tough. From a Buddhist perspective, the strategy could be to attempt to see all of the choices for motion in any state of affairs, to know all of the implications of every, to see your entire personal motivations and entanglements clearly, after which to deliberately make the best option that advantages the best variety of beings.

Clearly, what Buddhism is asking of us is exceedingly tough and even not possible. For instance, in case you’re making an attempt to stay an moral life, it’s simple sufficient to keep away from deliberately killing beings with your personal fingers. But what about your client decisions—shopping for meat or leather-based items, let’s say—that trigger beings to be killed by others? Okay, you say, so I’ll turn into a vegan. But even in case you purchase solely plant-based meals, aren’t you contributing to the dying of beings as their habitats are cleared to make room for agricultural fields? If you drive a automotive, aren’t you contributing to local weather change that kills off species? Even in case you maintain completely nonetheless and do nothing, if you realize that there are beings dying that you possibly can assist, but you don’t intervene, aren’t you contributing to their dying by means of your inaction? Upon deeper investigation, don’t most of our choices as fashionable human beings end result in hurt of some type or one other to different beings? How can we presumably navigate this thicket of contradictions and interconnections? Is it even potential to stay an moral life?

Thinking in phrases of karma doesn’t give us pat solutions to those questions, nevertheless it provides us instruments to assist transfer previous a simplistic understanding of ethics. It invitations us to query our actions from a number of angles and to judge our decisions and their penalties in the broadest phrases. For me, it’s right here that the Buddhist notion of karma is most helpful. Because I’m not Buddhist, I’m not in making the argument that karma is true in a scientific sense—that individuals are actually reborn in methods which might be decided by some cosmic checking account. But, nonetheless, I believe the thought of karma is extraordinarily priceless as an prolonged metaphor. Even if we don’t consider in rebirth, I believe karma can nonetheless be a great tool to assist us to assume extra clearly about our choices in a helpful and productive manner, in order to achieve perspective on how our actions have an effect on the different beings round us.

By the manner, after some consideration, I purchased three birds that day outdoors the temple. What would you’ve gotten carried out?

Excerpted from Buddhish: A Guide to the 20 Most Important Buddhist Ideas for the Curious and the Skeptical by C. Pierce Salguero (Beacon Press 2022). Reprinted with permission from Beacon Press.


Most Popular

Recent Comments